William James Fisher

This research was done by my uncle, John Farquhar, who spent many years exploring the life, military service, and death of William James Fisher of Seaford, Delaware.

William James Fisher Portrait, Courtesy Gettysburg (GETT42200)

William James Fisher, at the age of 17, received a civilian appointment as 2nd lieutenant to the 10th US Infantry, a regiment of the Regular Army, dated and signed by the Secretary of War and President Lincoln, August 1861. Congressman George P. Fisher (no direct relation) procured Fisher’s commission at the urging of Fisher’s father, Isaac Montgomery Fisher.

The Delaware Volunteer Regiments had no officer billets available for an unknown, uncredentialed teen. Officers left the Regular Standing Army Regiments to staff and train the newly formed Volunteer troops. It was a natural political move to staff these vacancies by appointing promising young men from Civilian Life. As the Fishers were strong Union, Lincoln men, young Fisher was one of twelve to be commissioned into this youngest regiment of the Old Army.

Through the Fisher Collection letters, we learn of Fisher’s service with the Regulars until his death in the wheat field, Battle of Gettysburg, early in the evening of July 2, 1863.

The purpose of this research is to flesh out the life and times of Lt. Fisher and to promote the story of a regular soldier, largely unknown to the Civil War community. His immediate family and descendants cherished the collection of letters and artifacts for many years. These became available for public view in a private museum located in New Market, VA., circa 1954. The collection was put up for auction in 2001. It was subsequently purchased and donated to the Gettysburg National Military Park (GNMP), and now resides in that location. Artifacts and letters of this Fisher Collection are on display, “William is No More,” at the new Museum & Visitor Center of the GNMP.

Who Were the Fishers?

According to the auction house Guernsey’s: William was the first born of Isaac Montgomery Fisher and Sarah Jane Vaughan [sic]. Isaac was born April 10, 1817 and died May 7, 1878 (age 58). He was the son of James Fisher and Bathsheba (maiden name unknown). William, born December 28, 1843 in a house in the vicinity of Seaford, Delaware was one of nine children. The property was granted by the Lord Baron of Baltimore to George Fisher on July 30, 1732 (Fisher’s Fancy, 100 acres) and was know as the Fisher Fancy Farm or Nanticoke Farm. The home was built by George who passed it down to his son James and then James passed it down to his son Isaac. James and Isaac were also born in this home.

Fisher Home Ca. 1890, Courtesy Gettysburg (GETT42205). Guernsey’s: Glass plate 14 x 11 inch photo of the 1732 Fisher Home. Unusual photo in between 2 panes of glass showing the 1732 Fisher home place. Standing in front of the kitchen are 5 women and 2 children of the Fisher family. Glass is framed with a brass chain 3/8 inches wide with 18 inches of chain to hang on wall. The Horse Soldier, Item Code # 41. Price: $50.00
Fisher Home, Courtesy Gettysburg (GETT42205), Detail
1868 Beers Map

Letters

In 1861, Williams’s father, Isaac Montgomery Fisher, requested assistance from William’s teacher, Samuel J. Witherbee, in getting William a commission. Below, Witherbee was responding to a letter from Isaac that he had received two days prior. The Mr. G. P. Fisher referred to was George Purnell Fisher, the lone Congressman from Delaware, who was not a direct relative.

July 13, 1861 [Saturday]
Mr. Fisher:

Dear Sir,

I received yours of the 11th & would say that I can heartily recommend your son in the particulars referred to. But I suppose my recommendation would have no influence where the selection proceeds from merit & not from favor.

I have no doubt William can pass the preliminary examination which is by no means a severe one.

I did not ask Mr. G. P. Fisher for an endorsement of this certificate, as his wife was dying, when I received your letter; he left immediately with her body for Connecticut.

Thanking you for your kind expression of sympathy for me in my bodily weakness.

Allow me to wish you a continuance of the blessing of health, with all other good [things].

Truly yours, S. J. Witherbee

On August 27, 1861, Isaac received a letter from George B. Rodney of New Castle, Delaware. The letter describes the process his son (George Rodney, 4th Artillery) underwent to gain a commission and advises that the cost of uniform, sword, etc. is $75.00.

New Castle, Delaware
August 27, 1861 [Tuesday]

I. M. Fisher, Esq.
Dear Sir.

I received your letter a few days since and I will give you all the information I possess.

After I had seen my son’s name, among those appointed by the President [Abraham Lincoln], I wrote for him [son George B.] to the Adjutant General [Lorenzo Thomas]. But the only answer given was the transmission of his commission. You might, with sincerity, do the same.

My son [George B. Rodney] sent forward his acceptance of the commission with the certificate of having later the oath required. He has since equipped himself with uniform & sword. He is now expecting to receive orders, but to what place he may be ordered is very uncertain.

All the appointments, including that of your son, I understand [are] to be in the Regular Army and will possibly be permanent.

The compensation of a Second Lieutenant is about $1000 per annum.

I had supposed there would be some examination, but as my son has received his commission, it will probably be omitted in his case.

He was a member of the Commonwealth Artillery Company of Philadelphia. [He] served 3 months, as such, at Fort Delaware. That fact may have dispensed with any examination, but, I am not certain that he will yet be examined.

He is between 18 & 19 years of age and, at the time he volunteered, was a clerk in a store in Philadelphia.

I would advise you to write on behalf of your son stating, that having seen his appointment Gazetted, he is awaiting instructions at his place of residence.

Yours very respectfully,
Geo. B. Rodney

P.S. If your son should conclude to get his outfit & will stop here [New Castle] on his way to the city [Wilmington], my son may give him some information as to the articles required, he having consulted Capt. Gibson of Fort Delaware on the subject.

The cost of his uniform, sword, etc., will be about $75.00

1861 Letters to Home

William wrote nine letters home in 1861, mostly covering his movements, gathering supplies, and details of his boarding arrangements where he complains about the high cost of living in Washington DC. There was an exciting incident when he arrested an officer who was suspected of being a woman and, under questioning, admitted to her fair sex, but was not found to be a Southern spy. Click on the image to read the letter and the transcription.

1862 Letters to Home

In 1862 William shook hands with President Lincoln; complained about the infrequency of letters from home; was grazed in the neck by a mini ball but not injured; witnessed mounds of rebel dead; and decided he’d had enough of soldiering and was making plans to buy a farm.

The November 10, 1862, letter image is missing but a translation is found here:

Nov 10th 1862 [Tuesday]. Camp near Warrenton, Va.
My Dear Father:
I received a letter from you dated Oct 31st while on the march and this is the first opportunity that I have had to answer it.
I am sure if John Francis was to go to the President and apply for a commission he could get it. Two thirds of the appointments in the army are made in that way. Go first to the Secretary of War and get, if he could, his recommendation and then direct to the President and I am sure he could get it. If he tries it he had better go to Lt. Col. Garesche of the Adjutant General’s department; He being from Delaware, I think, would interest himself in John’s case. He had better get a letter of recommendation from George P. Fisher. There are vacancies in almost every Regiment in the Army. In the 10th there are two.
General McClellan has been superseded and no officer or soldier, that I have seen, so far has any confidence in anybody else. It would not at all surprise me if we get whipped in the next fight. I believe they are trying to get Fremont to head the army again. If they do, I shall resign and go to South America and try something else; for I don’t like the idea of being killed under such man as Fremont.
I don’t feel like writing any more at present, so I’ll close.
Give my love to all. Your son, Will

1863 Letters to Home

Death on the Battlefield

Fisher was killed in action in the wheat field at the Battle of Gettysburg, PA, on July 2, 1863. He was 19 years old. His body was buried in a nearby farm and recovered later by his father, transported to Seaford, DE, and reburied in the Fisher Family Cemetery.

Tintype, Buchan & McCabe, Courtesy Gettysburg (GETT42191)

This photo is a quarter plate tintype (4 ¼ x 3 ¼ inches) of two men in Lt. Fisher’s company, Sergeant Terrance McCabe & Private John Buchan of Company H, who aided in taking the mortally wounded Fisher off the battlefield. Buchan, on the left, made the grave marker for Fisher’s temporary grave.

Temporary Wooden Grave Marker for Lt. W. J. Fisher, 10th US infantry (GETT 42189)
Grave Marker Verso

This original temporary grave marker was made by Private John Buchan after the death of Fisher and his subsequent burial in a field nearby. It measures 4.5” x 4.75″ x 0.25” and was carved and filled in with period ink on the field at Gettysburg July 2, 1863, and later mounted in a frame by the family. It sold in 2001 for $9,500 along with many other Fisher artifacts. The engraving reads “L.T. Fisher 10th U S I N F T”. After Fisher’s father, Isaac M. Fisher, retrieved the body, he added a further carving: “I found this body buried on the farm of Jacob Wiekert about 175 yards North West of the House along a crop fence.” On the rear of the frame a family member wrote, “This board marked the grave of Lieut. W. J. Fisher on the field of Battle of Gettysburg July 2d 1863.”

The Jacob Weikert house was a farmhouse on the Gettysburg battlefield that served as a temporary field hospital during the Battle of Gettysburg. It is now also known as the Rose Farm. During the battle, the house and surrounding property were used to care for the wounded from both armies, and a 15-year-old girl named Tilly Pierce stayed there, providing assistance. The home of Jacob Weikert was at the north, north west section of Little Round Top north of Wheatfield road. The present day Weikert house was originally a log cabin type that burned after the battle. In 1877 the Althoffs bought the property and built the present structure which reverted back to the Weikert name when the GNMP took it over.

Little Round Top

Fisher Family Cemetery

The Fisher Family Cemetery is located in the Southwest quadrant formed by the junction of Coverdale Road and the Seashore Highway (route 404). Striding approximately 800 feet due west of Jones Dogwood Drive street sign and approximately another 800 feet due south of a green power marker on route 18/404 will take you to a rectangular plot measuring about 575 feet in the North/South axis and 475 feet in the East/West axis in Seaford Hundred, which was split off from the former Northwest Fork Hundred by an Act of the Delaware General Assembly in 1869, in Sussex County, Delaware.

Fisher Cemetery Map

Much of the original cast iron fencing (it is assumed that the entire plot was enclosed) is gone. What is left is in sad condition.

Fisher Family Cemetery
Fisher Family Cemetery, Bridgeville, DE

The headstones face in a westerly direction. The three Fisher homes noted in the Beers Atlas of 1868 no longer exist, and their foundations have disappeared in the seasonal tilling of the acreage, at least since 1954 when James Fisher Morgan sold the property to the current owners. Thus, the orientation of the cemetery to the Fisher home(s) is unknown. All that remains is the run-down fencing, overgrown weeds, numerous groundhog burrows, some trash, and the grave markers.

Fisher Family Cemetery
Fisher Family Cemetery, Bridgeville, DE

Through the efforts of Paul Pool, local Civil War buff and Confederate Re-enactor of a Florida unit, the Veterans Administration is willing to replace Lt. Fisher’s marker with a more modern headstone, so that the current one can be preserved in the Seaford Historical Society Museum (SHSM) for protection from weather and acid rain. These conditions are dissolving the inscriptions on Fisher’s headstone (See photos # 3 & 4 & 5 to compare with the original photo #6 in the Fisher collection). Brad Temple’s charcoal rubbing brings the inscription to life and makes it legible.

Brad Temple’s Charcoal Rubbing of the William James Fisher Tombstone

It reads: “William J. Fisher Commissioned Captain Aug 2, 1862. Son of Isaac M. & S. J. Fisher, He was 1st Lieutenant of The 10th U. S. Infantry, Commissioned by Pres. Lincoln Aug 5th, 1861 and showed In all the Battles of the Army of the Potomac til the 2nd of July 1863 When He Fell At Gettysburg, Pa, Aged 19 years, 6 Mons & 4 Days.” The capstone (top of the marker) reads: Wm. James Fisher. A smaller stone, by two/thirds, marks the foot of his grave.

William J. Fisher Headstone
William J. Fisher Headstone. See https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/54968206/william_james-fisher for a clear photo.
William J. Fisher Headstone, Courtesy Gettysburg Museum, GETT-42198

Permission by the current owner to proceed with the replacement of the marker has not yet been obtained. The Seaford Historical Society (SHS) has been advised to let the matter rest for the time being as the current owner is fearful of “sightseers” tramping over active farmlands, and rightly so. Of course, if the headstone is preserved in the museum, there will be no need to tramp over growing money crops. No current relative has been found to date to adjudicate the situation.

The cemetery also includes the remains of the following family members: Father & Mother, Isaac Montgomery Fisher and Sarah Jane Fisher; two sisters, Alice Annie Fisher and Eliza Emily Fisher; and a brother Jacob Fisher. Three nephews are also interred there: William M. Morgan, Robert Elmer Fisher, and Francis Callaway Fisher.

The following headstones in the Family Cemetery are inscribed thus:

Isaac Montgomery Fisher, son of James and Bathsheba nee Fisher (no relation) Fisher. Born April 10, 1817. Died May 7, 1878 Sarah Jane Vaughan, daughter of William and Alice nee Bloxom Vaughan and wife of Isaac Montgomery Fisher. Born Feb 23, 1822. Died June 25, 1907. (The grave contains both parents marked by a single modern granite engraved stone as noted above.)

Isaac Fisher Gravestone

Alice Annie [Fisher], daughter of Isaac M. and Sarah J. Fisher. Died Nov 7, 1853 in the 5th year of her age. Suffer the little children to come unto me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God. (The passage is from Mark, Chapter 10, verse 14.)

Alice Annie Fisher

Jacob [Fisher], son of Isaac M. & Sarah Fisher. Born & Died April 5th, 1858.

Jacob Fisher

Eliza Emily [Fisher], daughter of Isaac M. and Sarah J. Fisher. Born Oct 5th 1860. Died May 9th, 1861. (The inscription that follows is unfortunately illegible.)

William M. Morgan, son of H.H. & Mary F. Morgan. Born Jun 7, 1874. Died July 6, 1903. (Mary Frances Morgan was Lt. Fisher’s sister.)

William M Morgan Headstone

Francis Callaway [Rogers], son of George R. [Rogers] and Sarah A. [Ann] Fisher. Born Sep 23rd 1875. Died March 7th, 1876. (A footstone reads: F. C. F. George Rogers was Lt. Fisher’s second oldest brother.)

Francis Callaway Rogers

Robert Elmer [Fisher], son of R. [Robert] W. [Welles] & M. [Margaret] T. [Terry] Fisher. Born Dec 10, 1893. Died Aug 12, 1955. (This head stone is a modern granite memorial. A footstone reads: R E F. Robert Welles was Lt. Fisher’s youngest brother whose existence he never knew, as his death in battle preceded the birth of the former.)

Robert Elmer Fisher Headstone

The graves occupy the Western half of the cemetery. The Eastern half appears empty of markers, but is piled high with dirt and vegetation. An archaeological dig is necessary to determine what lies beneath, if anything. To date, no graves in the Seaford/Bridgeville/Concord cemeteries have been located for any other family members (Fisher, Morgan, or Morse).

Meet the Author

John Farquhar has been a dedicated Civil War buff since the fall of 1949 when, at age 13, he and his mother first visited the Gettysburg battlefield, stopping and reading every historical sign on the way from their home in Kennett Square, Pennsylvania. They roomed in a private home at 13-11 (today’s Postal address) Steinwehr Avenue, today known as “The Strip,” next to the present-day Avenue Restaurant.

Farquhar received an B.A. degree from Gettysburg College in 1958. While there, he paid little attention to the Gettysburg National Military Park (GNPG). He graduated with a dental degree from the University of Pennsylvania in 1962. He opened his dental practice in Seaford, Delaware, and retired in 1999.

A past board member of the Friends of the National Park of Gettysburg (FNPG), now reorganized as the Friends of the Gettysburg Foundation (FGF), Farquhar guided the FNPG toward more land preservation. He provided Pig ‘n the Poke tours to sites rarely visited on the battlefield as part of FNPG programs to raise funds for land purchase to preserve the integrity of the battlefields and that of the surrounding land.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eighteen − fifteen =