James O’Reilly married Patrick Cavanagh and Bridget Murray in 1868 in Cleveland, Ohio. Here is some info I found on him at http://www.irisharchives.org/pdf/PioneerPriests.pdf.

1868-James O'Reilly, Priest who married Patrick and Bridget

1868-James O’Reilly, Priest who married Patrick Cavanagh and Bridget Murray